aboutsummaryrefslogtreecommitdiff
path: root/src/interp/category.boot
blob: beabe110761914586643fc4914bab4df25f07219 (plain)
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
381
382
383
384
385
386
387
388
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
401
402
403
404
405
406
407
408
409
410
411
412
413
414
415
416
417
418
419
420
421
422
423
424
425
426
427
428
429
430
431
432
433
434
435
436
437
438
439
440
441
442
443
444
445
446
447
448
449
450
451
452
453
454
455
456
457
458
459
460
461
462
463
464
465
466
467
468
469
470
471
472
473
474
475
476
477
478
479
480
481
482
483
484
485
486
487
488
489
490
491
492
493
494
495
496
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
513
514
515
516
517
518
519
520
521
522
523
524
525
526
527
528
529
530
531
532
533
534
535
536
537
538
539
540
541
542
543
544
545
546
547
548
549
550
551
552
553
554
555
556
557
558
559
560
561
562
563
564
565
566
567
568
569
570
571
572
573
574
575
576
577
-- Copyright (c) 1991-2002, The Numerical Algorithms Group Ltd.
-- All rights reserved.
-- Copyright (C) 2007-2010, Gabriel Dos Reis.
-- All rights reserved.
--
-- Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
-- modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions are
-- met:
--
--     - Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright
--       notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
--
--     - Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright
--       notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in
--       the documentation and/or other materials provided with the
--       distribution.
--
--     - Neither the name of The Numerical Algorithms Group Ltd. nor the
--       names of its contributors may be used to endorse or promote products
--       derived from this software without specific prior written permission.
--
-- THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE COPYRIGHT HOLDERS AND CONTRIBUTORS "AS
-- IS" AND ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED
-- TO, THE IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A
-- PARTICULAR PURPOSE ARE DISCLAIMED. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE COPYRIGHT OWNER
-- OR CONTRIBUTORS BE LIABLE FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL,
-- EXEMPLARY, OR CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO,
-- PROCUREMENT OF SUBSTITUTE GOODS OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR
-- PROFITS; OR BUSINESS INTERRUPTION) HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY OF
-- LIABILITY, WHETHER IN CONTRACT, STRICT LIABILITY, OR TORT (INCLUDING
-- NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE) ARISING IN ANY WAY OUT OF THE USE OF THIS
-- SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGE.


import g_-util
import g_-cndata
namespace BOOT

--%

++ List of global attributes.
$Attributes := []

$NewCatVec := nil

--%

++ Returns true if `a' is a category (runtime) object.
isCategory: %Thing -> %Boolean
isCategory a == 
  REFVECP a and #a > 5 and getShellEntry(a,3) = $Category

++ Return true if the form `x' designates an instantiaion of a
++ category constructor known to the global database or the
++ envronement `e'.
isCategoryForm: (%Form,%Env) -> %Boolean
isCategoryForm(x,e) ==
  atom x => u:= get(x,"macro",e) => isCategoryForm(u,e)
  categoryForm? first x
 
--% Functions for building categories
 
CategoryPrint(D,$e) ==
  SAY "--------------------------------------"
  SAY "Name (and arguments) of category:"
  PRETTYPRINT D.0
  SAY "operations:"
  PRETTYPRINT D.1
  SAY "attributes:"
  PRETTYPRINT D.2
  SAY "This is a sub-category of"
  PRETTYPRINT first D.4
  for u in second D.4 repeat
    SAY("This has an alternate view: slot ",rest u," corresponds to ",first u)
  for u in third D.4 repeat
    SAY("This has a local domain: slot ",rest u," corresponds to ",first u)
  for j in 6..MAXINDEX D repeat
    u:= D.j
    null u => SAY "another domain"
    atom first u => SAY("Alternate View corresponding to: ",u)
    PRETTYPRINT u

++ Returns a fresly built category object for a domain or package
++ (as indicated by `domainOrPackage'), with signature list
++ designated by `sigList', attribute list designated by `attList',
++ used domains list designated by `domList', and a princical ancestor
++ category object designated by `PrincipalAncestor'.
mkCategory: (%Symbol,%List,%List,%List, %Maybe %Shell) -> %Shell
mkCategory(domainOrPackage,sigList,attList,domList,PrincipalAncestor) ==
  NSigList := nil
  -- Unless extending a principal ancestor (from the end), start
  -- from the first free, unencumbered slot.
  count := 
    PrincipalAncestor = nil => $NRTbase
    #PrincipalAncestor
  sigList:=
    [if s is [sig,pred]
       then
         -- Don't retain duplicate signatures.
         -- ??? Should we not check for predicate subsumption too?
         or/[x is [[ =sig,.,:impl],:num] for x in NSigList] => [sig,pred,:impl]
                 --only needed for multiple copies of sig
         num:= if domainOrPackage="domain" then count else count-5
         nsig:= mkOperatorEntry(sig,pred,num)
         NSigList:= [[nsig,:count],:NSigList]
         count:= count+1
         nsig
     else s for s in sigList]
  NewLocals:= nil
  for s in sigList repeat
    NewLocals:= union(NewLocals,Prepare CADAR s) where
      Prepare u == "union"/[Prepare2 v for v in u]
      Prepare2 v ==
        v is "$" => nil
        string? v => nil
        atom v => [v]
        MEMQ(first v,$PrimitiveDomainNames) => nil
          --This variable is set in INIT LISP
          --It is a list of all the domains that we need not cache
        v is ["Union",:w] =>
          "union"/[Prepare2 x for x in stripUnionTags w]
        v is ["Mapping",:w] => "union"/[Prepare2 x for x in w]
        v is ["List",w] => Prepare2 w
        v is ["Record",.,:w] => "union"/[Prepare2 third x for x in w]
        [v]
  OldLocals:= nil
  -- Remove possible duplicate local domain caches.
  if PrincipalAncestor then 
    for u in (OldLocals:= third PrincipalAncestor.4) repeat 
      NewLocals := delete(first u,NewLocals)
  -- New local domains caches are hosted in slots at the end onward
  for u in NewLocals repeat
    OldLocals := [[u,:count],:OldLocals]
    count := count+1
  -- Build a fresh category object stuffed with all updated information
  v := newShell count
  v.0 := nil
  v.1 := sigList
  v.2 := attList
  v.3 := $Category
  if PrincipalAncestor ~= nil then
    for x in 6..#PrincipalAncestor-1 repeat 
      v.x := PrincipalAncestor.x
    v.4 := [first PrincipalAncestor.4,second PrincipalAncestor.4,OldLocals]
  else v.4 := [nil,nil,OldLocals] --associated categories and domains
  v.5 := domList
  for [nsig,:sequence] in NSigList repeat 
    v.sequence := nsig
  v

--% Subsumption code (for operators)
 
DropImplementations (a is [sig,pred,:implem]) ==
  if implem is [[q,:.]] and (q="ELT" or q="CONST")
     then if (q="ELT")  then [sig,pred]
                        else [[:sig,:'(constant)],pred]
     else a
 
SigListUnion(extra,original) ==
  --augments original %with everything in extra that is not in original
  for (o:=[[ofn,osig,:.],opred,:.]) in original repeat
    -- The purpose of this loop is to detect cases when the
    -- original list contains, e.g. ** with NonNegativeIntegers, and
    -- the extra list would like to add ** with PositiveIntegers.
    -- The PI map is therefore gives an implementation of "Subsumed"
    for x in SigListOpSubsume(o,extra) repeat
      [[xfn,xsig,:.],xpred,:.]:=x
      xfn=ofn and xsig=osig =>
              --checking name and signature, but not a 'constant' marker
        xpred=opred => extra:= delete(x,extra)
             --same signature and same predicate
        opred = true => extra:= delete(x,extra)
   -- PRETTYPRINT ("we ought to subsume",x,o)
      not MachineLevelSubsume(QCAR o,QCAR x) =>
         '"Source level subsumption not implemented"
      extra:= delete(x,extra)
  for e in extra repeat
    [esig,epred,:.]:= e
    eimplem:=[]
    for x in SigListOpSubsume(e,original) repeat
        --PRETTYPRINT(LIST("SigListOpSubsume",e,x))
      not MachineLevelSubsume(QCAR e,QCAR x) =>
        --systemError '"Source level subsumption not implemented"
        original:= [e,:original]
        return nil -- this exits from the innermost for loop
      original:= delete(x,original)
      [xsig,xpred,:ximplem]:= x
--      if xsig ~= esig then   -- not quite strong enough
      if first xsig ~= first esig or second xsig ~= second esig then
-- the new version won't get confused by "constant"markers
         if ximplem is [["Subsumed",:.],:.] then
            original := [x,:original]
          else
            original:= [[xsig,xpred,["Subsumed",:esig]],:original]
       else epred:=mkOr(epred,xpred)
-- this used always to be done, as noted below, but that's not safe
      if not(ximplem is [["Subsumed",:.],:.]) then eimplem:= ximplem
      if eimplem then esig:=[first esig,second esig] 
           -- in case there's a constant marker
      e:= [esig,epred,:eimplem]
--    e:= [esig,mkOr(xpred,epred),:ximplem]
-- Original version -gets it wrong if the new operator is only
-- present under certain conditions
        -- We must pick up the previous implementation, if any
--+
      if ximplem is [[q,.,index]] and integer? index and (q="ELT" or q="CONST")
        then $NewCatVec. index:= e
    original:= [e,:original]
  original
 
mkOr: (%Form,%Form) -> %Form
mkOr(a,b) ==
  a=true => true
  b=true => true
  b=a => a
--PRETTYPRINT ("Condition merging",a,b)
  l:=
    a is ["OR",:a'] =>
      (b is ["OR",:b'] => union(a',b'); mkOr2(b,a') )
    b is ["OR",:b'] => mkOr2(a,b')
    (a is ["has",avar,acat]) and (b is ["has",=avar,bcat]) =>
      DescendantP(acat,bcat) => [b]
      DescendantP(bcat,acat) => [a]
      [a,b]
    a is ['AND,:a'] and member(b,a') => [b]
    b is ['AND,:b'] and member(a,b') => [a]
    a is ["and",:a'] and member(b,a') => [b]
    b is ["and",:b'] and member(a,b') => [a]
    [a,b]
  #l = 1 => first l
  ["OR",:l]
 
mkOr2: (%Form,%Form) -> %Form
mkOr2(a,b) ==
  --a is a condition, "b" a list of them
  member(a,b) => b
  a is ["has",avar,acat] =>
    aRedundant:=false
    for c in b | c is ["has",=avar,ccat] repeat
      DescendantP(acat,ccat) =>
        return (aRedundant:=true)
      if DescendantP(ccat,acat) then b := delete(c,b)
    aRedundant => b
    [a,:b]
  [a,:b]
 
mkAnd: (%Form,%Form) -> %Form
mkAnd(a,b) ==
  a=true => b
  b=true => a
  b=a => a
  --PRETTYPRINT ("Condition merging",a,b)
  l:=
    a is ["AND",:a'] =>
      (b is ["AND",:b'] => union(a',b'); mkAnd2(b,a') )
    b is ["AND",:b'] => mkAnd2(a,b')
    (a is ["has",avar,acat]) and (b is ["has",=avar,bcat]) =>
      DescendantP(acat,bcat) => [a]
      DescendantP(bcat,acat) => [b]
      [a,b]
    [a,b]
  #l = 1 => first l
  ["AND",:l]
 
mkAnd2: (%Form,%Form) -> %Form
mkAnd2(a,b) ==
  --a is a condition, "b" a list of them
  member(a,b) => b
  a is ["has",avar,acat] =>
    aRedundant:=false
    for c in b | c is ["has",=avar,ccat] repeat
      DescendantP(ccat,acat) =>
        return (aRedundant:=true)
      if DescendantP(acat,ccat) then b := delete(c,b)
    aRedundant => b
    [a,:b]
  [a,:b]
 
SigListMember(m,list) ==
  list=nil => false
  SigEqual(m,first list) => true
  SigListMember(m,rest list)
 
SigEqual([sig1,pred1,:.],[sig2,pred2,:.]) ==
  -- Notice asymmetry: checks that arg1 is a consequence of arg2
  sig1=sig2 and PredImplies(pred2,pred1)
 
PredImplies(a,b) ==
    --true if a => b in the sense of logical implication
--a = "true" => true
  a=true => true
  a=b => true
  false         -- added by RDJ: 12/21/82
--error()       -- for the time being
 
SigListOpSubsume([[name1,sig1,:.],:.],list) ==
  --does m subsume another operator in the list?
        --see "operator subsumption" in SYSTEM SCRIPT
        --if it does, returns the subsumed member
  lsig1 := #sig1
  ans:=[]
  for (n:=[[name2,sig2,:.],:.]) in list repeat
    name1=name2 and lsig1 = #sig2 and sig1 = sig2 =>
      ans:=[n,:ans]
  return ans
 
MachineLevelSubsume([name1,[out1,:in1],:flag1],[name2,[out2,:in2],:flag2]) ==
  -- Checks for machine-level subsumption in the sense of SYSTEM SCRIPT
  --  true if the first signature subsumes the second
  --  flag1 = flag2 and: this really should be checked, but
  name1=name2 and MachineLevelSubset(out1,out2) and
    (and/[MachineLevelSubset(inarg2,inarg1) for inarg1 in in1 for inarg2 in in2]
      )
 
MachineLevelSubset(a,b) ==
  --true if a is a machine-level subset of b
  a=b => true
  b is ["Union",:blist] and member(a,blist) and
    (and/[string? x for x in blist | x~=a]) => true
           --all other branches must be distinct objects
  not null isSubDomain(a,b)
             --we assume all subsets are true at the machine level
 
--% Ancestor chasing code
 
FindFundAncs l ==
  --l is a list of categories and associated conditions (a list of 2-lists
  --returns a list of them and all their fundamental ancestors
  --also as two-lists with the appropriate conditions
  l=nil => nil
  f1:= CatEval CAAR l
  f1.0=nil => FindFundAncs rest l
  ans:= FindFundAncs rest l
  for u in FindFundAncs [[CatEval first x,mkAnd(CADAR l,second x)]
   for x in second f1.4] repeat
    x:= ASSQ(first u,ans) =>
      ans:= [[first u,mkOr(second x,second u)],:delete(x,ans)]
    ans:= [u,:ans]
        --testing to see if first l is already there
  x:= ASSQ(CAAR l,ans) => [[CAAR l,mkOr(CADAR l,second x)],:delete(x,ans)]
  CADAR l=true =>
    for x in first f1.4 repeat if y:= ASSQ(CatEval x,ans) then ans:= delete(y,ans)
    [first l,:ans]
  for x in first f1.4 repeat
    if y:= ASSQ(CatEval x,ans) then ans:=
      [[first y,mkOr(CADAR l,second y)],:delete(y,ans)]
  [first l,:ans]
  -- Our new thing may have, as an alternate view, a principal
  -- descendant of something previously added which is therefore
  -- subsumed
 
CatEval: %Thing -> %Shell
CatEval x ==
  REFVECP x => x
  e := 
    $InteractiveMode => $CategoryFrame
    $e
  (compMakeCategoryObject(x,e)).expr
 
--RemovePrinAncs(l,leaves) ==
--  l=nil => nil
--  leaves:= [first y for y in leaves]
--               --remove the slot pointers
--  [x for x in l | not AncestorP(x.0,leaves)]
 
AncestorP: (%Form, %List) -> %Form
AncestorP(xname,leaves) ==
  -- checks for being a principal ancestor of one of the leaves
  member(xname,leaves) => xname
  for y in leaves repeat
    member(xname,first CatEval(y).4) => return y
 
CondAncestorP(xname,leaves,condition) ==
  -- checks for being a principal ancestor of one of the leaves
  for u in leaves repeat
    u':=first u
    ucond:=
      null rest u => true
      second u
    xname = u' or member(xname,first CatEval(u').4) =>
      PredImplies(ucond,condition) => return u'


++ Returns true if the form `a' designates a category that is any 
++ kind of descendant of the category designated by the form `b'.
DescendantP: (%Form,%Form) -> %Boolean
DescendantP(a,b) ==
  a=b => true
  a is ["ATTRIBUTE",:.] => false
  a is ["SIGNATURE",:.] => false
  a:= CatEval a
  b is ["ATTRIBUTE",b'] =>
    (l:=assoc(b',a.2)) => TruthP second l
  member(b,first a.4) => true
  AncestorP(b,[first u for u in second a.4]) => true
  false
 
--% The implementation of Join
 
JoinInner(l,$e) ==
  $NewCatVec: local := nil
  CondList:= nil
  for u in l repeat
    for at in u.2 repeat
      at2:= first at
      if atom at2 then at2:=[at2]
        -- the variable $Attributes is built globally, so that true
        -- attributes can be detected without calling isCategoryForm
      QMEMQ(QCAR at2,$Attributes) => nil
      null isCategoryForm(at2,$e) =>
        $Attributes:=[QCAR at2,:$Attributes]
        nil
      pred:= second at
        -- The predicate under which this category is conditional
      member(pred,get("$Information","special",$e)) => l:= [:l,CatEval at2]
          --It's true, so we add this as unconditional
      not (pred is ["and",:.]) => CondList:= [[CatEval at2,pred],:CondList]
      pred':=
        [u
          for u in rest pred | not member(u,get("$Information","special",$e))
            and not (u=true)]
      null pred' => l:= [:l,CatEval at2]
      # pred'=1 => CondList:= [[CatEval at2,pred'],:CondList]
      CondList:= [[CatEval at2,["and",:pred']],:CondList]
  [$NewCatVec,:l]:= l
  l':= [:CondList,:[[u,true] for u in l]]
    -- This is a list of all the categories that this extends
    -- conditionally or unconditionally
  sigl:= $NewCatVec.1
  attl:= $NewCatVec.2
  globalDomains:= $NewCatVec.5
  FundamentalAncestors:= second $NewCatVec.4
  if $NewCatVec.0 then FundamentalAncestors:=
    [[$NewCatVec.0],:FundamentalAncestors]
                    --principal ancestor . all those already included
  copied:= nil
  originalVector:= true
  -- we can not decide to extend the vector in multiple ways
  -- this flag helps us detect this case
  originalVector := false
    -- this skips buggy code which discards needed categories
  for [b,condition] in FindFundAncs l' repeat
      --This loop implements Category Subsumption
          --as described in SYSTEM SCRIPT
    if not (b.0=nil) then
                   --It's a named category
      bname:= b.0
      CondAncestorP(bname,FundamentalAncestors,condition) => nil
      (f:=AncestorP(bname,[first u for u in FundamentalAncestors])) =>
        [.,.,index]:=assoc(f,FundamentalAncestors)
        FundamentalAncestors:=[[bname,condition,index],:FundamentalAncestors]
      PrinAncb:= first CatEval(bname).4
               --Principal Ancestors of b
      reallynew:= true
      for anc in FundamentalAncestors repeat
        if member(first anc,PrinAncb) then
                  --This is the check for "Category Subsumption"
          if rest anc
             then (anccond:= second anc; ancindex:= third anc)
             else (anccond:= true; ancindex:= nil)
          if PredImplies(condition,anccond)
             then FundamentalAncestors:=
 
               -- the new 'b' is more often true than the old one 'anc'
              [[bname,condition,ancindex],:delete(anc,FundamentalAncestors)]
           else
            if ancindex and (PredImplies(anccond,condition); true)
-- I have no idea who effectively commented out the predImplies
-- JHD 25/8/86
               then
                     --the new 'b' is less often true
                newentry:=[bname,condition,ancindex]
                if not member(newentry,FundamentalAncestors) then
                  FundamentalAncestors:= [newentry,:FundamentalAncestors]
             else ancindex:= nil
          if not copied then
            $NewCatVec:= COPY_-SEQ $NewCatVec
            copied:= true
          if ancindex
             then ($NewCatVec.ancindex:= bname; reallynew:= nil)
             else
              if originalVector and (condition=true) then
                $NewCatVec:= CatEval bname
                copied:= nil
                FundamentalAncestors:= [[bname],:second $NewCatVec.4]
                         --bname is Principal, so comes first
                reallynew:= nil
                MEMQ(b,l) =>
                       --MEMQ since category vectors are guaranteed unique
                  (sigl:= $NewCatVec.1; attl:= $NewCatVec.2; l:= delete(b,l))
             --     SAY("domain ",bname," subsumes")
             --     SAY("adding a conditional domain ",
             --         bname,
             --         " replacing",
             --         first anc)
                bCond:= ASSQ(b,CondList)
                CondList:= delete(bCond,CondList)
             -- value of bCond not used and could be NIL
             -- bCond:= second bCond
                globalDomains:= $NewCatVec.5
                for u in $NewCatVec.1 repeat
                  if not member(u,sigl) then
                    [s,c,i]:= u
                    if c=true
                       then sigl:= [[s,condition,i],:sigl]
                       else sigl:= [[s,["and",condition,c],i],:sigl]
                for u in $NewCatVec.2 repeat
                  if not member(u,attl) then
                    [a,c]:= u
                    if c=true
                       then attl:= [[a,condition],:attl]
                       else attl:= [[a,["and",condition,c]],:attl]
      if reallynew then
        n:= SIZE $NewCatVec
        FundamentalAncestors:= [[b.0,condition,n],:FundamentalAncestors]
        $NewCatVec:= LENGTHENVEC($NewCatVec,n+1)
-- We need to copy the vector otherwise the FundamentalAncestors
-- list will get stepped on while compiling "If R has ... " code
-- Camm Maguire July 26, 2003
--        copied:= true
        copied:= false
        originalvector:= false
        $NewCatVec.n:= b.0
  if not copied then $NewCatVec:= COPY_-SEQ $NewCatVec
    -- It is important to copy the vector now,
    -- in case SigListUnion alters it while
    -- performing Operator Subsumption
  for b in l repeat
    sigl:= SigListUnion([DropImplementations u for u in b.1],sigl)
    attl:=
-- next two lines are merely performance improvements
      MEMQ(attl,b.2) => b.2
      MEMQ(b.2,attl) => attl
      S_+(b.2,attl)
    globalDomains:= [:globalDomains,:S_-(b.5,globalDomains)]
  for b in CondList repeat
    newpred:= second b
    for u in (first b).2 repeat
      v:= assoc(first u,attl)
      null v =>
        attl:=
          second u=true => [[first u,newpred],:attl]
          [[first u,["and",newpred,second u]],:attl]
      second v=true => nil
      attl:= delete(v,attl)
      attl:=
        second u=true => [[first u,mkOr(second v,newpred)],:attl]
        [[first u,mkOr(second v,mkAnd(newpred,second u))],:attl]
    sigl:=
      SigListUnion(
        [AddPredicate(DropImplementations u,newpred) for u in (first b).1],sigl) where
          AddPredicate(op is [sig,oldpred,:implem],newpred) ==
            newpred=true => op
            oldpred=true => [sig,newpred,:implem]
            [sig,mkpf([oldpred,newpred],"and"),:implem]
  FundamentalAncestors:= [x for x in FundamentalAncestors | rest x]
               --strip out the pointer to Principal Ancestor
  c:= first $NewCatVec.4
  pName:= $NewCatVec.0
  if pName and not member(pName,c) then c:= [pName,:c]
  $NewCatVec.4:= [c,FundamentalAncestors,third $NewCatVec.4]
  mkCategory("domain",sigl,attl,globalDomains,$NewCatVec)

Join(:l) ==
  e :=
    null $e or $InteractiveMode => $CategoryFrame
    $e
  JoinInner(l, e)
 
--ProduceDomainAlist(u,e) ==
--  -- Gives a complete Alist for all the functions in the Domain
--  not (sig:= get(u,"modemap",e)) => nil
--  sig:= CADAAR sig
--                       --an incantation
--  [c,.,.]:= compMakeCategoryObject(sig,e)
--  -- We assume that the environment need not be kept
--  c.1